Then answered Simon, and said, Pray ye to the Lord for me, that none of these things which ye have spoken come upon me. Simon's response to Peter's rebuke appears focused on avoiding judgment rather than genuine repentance, revealing a heart still unconverted.
The request pray ye to the Lord for me could indicate genuine contrition, yet the motivation clause—that none of these things...come upon me—suggests self-centered concern about consequences rather than grief over sin itself. True repentance laments offending God; false repentance fears only punishment.
Simon asks apostles to pray rather than praying himself, possibly revealing continued belief in human intermediaries' special power. He doesn't acknowledge his wickedness directly nor express desire for holiness—only for escape from threatened judgment. This parallels Pharaoh's repeated false repentances in Exodus, seeking relief without heart change.
Reformed theology distinguishes between attrition (sorrow from fear of punishment) and contrition (sorrow from love of God). Simon exhibits attrition at best. The text doesn't record his ultimate fate, leaving his conversion ambiguous—a sobering warning that religious profession doesn't guarantee salvation.
Historical Context
Ancient sources diverge on Simon's fate. Luke's account ends here without resolution. Church fathers like Irenaeus and Justin Martyr identify Simon as founding figure of Gnosticism, suggesting he didn't truly convert. Others allow possibility of genuine later repentance.
The ambiguity serves didactic purpose—examining our own hearts rather than judging Simon's eternal state. First-century Christianity encountered many like Simon: attracted to Christianity's power and community without genuine submission to Christ's lordship. Around 35-37 CE, this incident taught early believers to maintain discernment about genuine versus spurious faith.
Questions for Reflection
How can we distinguish between fear-motivated repentance and genuine godly sorrow?
What does Simon's request for intercession reveal about his understanding of relationship with God?
In what ways might modern Christians seek benefits of Christianity while avoiding genuine submission to Christ?
How should churches respond to those who exhibit external compliance without evident heart transformation?
What does the unresolved nature of Simon's story teach about presuming on others' eternal destinies?
Related Resources
Explore related topics, people, and study resources to deepen your understanding of this passage.
Analysis & Commentary
Then answered Simon, and said, Pray ye to the Lord for me, that none of these things which ye have spoken come upon me. Simon's response to Peter's rebuke appears focused on avoiding judgment rather than genuine repentance, revealing a heart still unconverted.
The request pray ye to the Lord for me could indicate genuine contrition, yet the motivation clause—that none of these things...come upon me—suggests self-centered concern about consequences rather than grief over sin itself. True repentance laments offending God; false repentance fears only punishment.
Simon asks apostles to pray rather than praying himself, possibly revealing continued belief in human intermediaries' special power. He doesn't acknowledge his wickedness directly nor express desire for holiness—only for escape from threatened judgment. This parallels Pharaoh's repeated false repentances in Exodus, seeking relief without heart change.
Reformed theology distinguishes between attrition (sorrow from fear of punishment) and contrition (sorrow from love of God). Simon exhibits attrition at best. The text doesn't record his ultimate fate, leaving his conversion ambiguous—a sobering warning that religious profession doesn't guarantee salvation.