Matthew 12:38
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Original Language Analysis
Cross References
Historical Context
Scribes and Pharisees represented religious establishment—trained in Torah, respected as authorities. Their demand for sign echoes Israel's wilderness pattern: despite witnessing plagues, Red Sea crossing, manna, cloud/fire, they repeatedly demanded signs (Exodus 17:2-7, Numbers 14:11, 22). Jesus had already performed numerous miracles throughout Galilee: healings, exorcisms, feeding multitudes, nature miracles. Yet they wanted different kind of sign—perhaps celestial phenomenon (Joshua's long day, Hezekiah's sundial reversal) or unmistakable divine voice. Their demand was both unbelieving (rejecting existing evidence) and presumptuous (dictating terms to God). Similar pattern appears in John 6:30: after feeding 5000, crowd asks 'What sign showest thou?' Jesus identifies this as evil generation (v.39)—characterizing entire attitude as wicked. Early church faced similar demands: pagans wanted spectacular proof; gnostics demanded special knowledge. But gospel centers on cross and resurrection—offensive to human pride, requiring humble faith. Throughout history, apologetics provides reasons for faith, but no amount of evidence compels belief without Spirit's work.
Questions for Reflection
- When do legitimate questions about faith become illegitimate demands for God to prove Himself on your terms?
- Why doesn't more evidence automatically produce faith—what's the relationship between evidence and belief?
- How do you respond when skeptics dismiss existing evidence while demanding different kinds of proof?
Related Resources
Explore related topics, people, and study resources to deepen your understanding of this passage.
Analysis & Commentary
'Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.' Despite witnessing countless miracles, scribes and Pharisees demand 'a sign' (σημεῖον/sēmeion)—validating miracle. The word 'Master' (Διδάσκαλε/Didaskale, teacher) feigns respect while hearts remain hostile. Reformed theology recognizes this pattern: unbelief demands more evidence while rejecting already-given evidence. They'd witnessed healings, exorcisms, nature miracles—yet want additional sign. This demonstrates problem isn't insufficient evidence but hardened hearts. Jesus's response (v.39-40) rebukes them: only sign they'll receive is Jonah's sign (death and resurrection). The request reveals several errors:
The pattern continues: skeptics demand proof while dismissing existing evidence. Faith doesn't come from irrefutable proof but from humble receptivity to available evidence.