John the Baptist, imprisoned by Herod, sends disciples to Jesus: 'Art thou he that should come, or do we look for another?' (συ ει ο ερχομενος η ετερον προσδοκωμεν). John's question reveals human doubt amid suffering. The one who proclaimed Jesus as Lamb of God (John 1:29) now questions. 'He that should come' (ο ερχομενος) refers to Messiah. John expected messianic judgment and kingdom establishment; instead he languishes in prison while Jesus teaches and heals. Suffering tests faith. John's honest question isn't unbelief but wrestling with unfulfilled expectations. Jesus welcomes honest questions and provides evidence rather than rebuke.
Historical Context
John imprisoned at Machaerus fortress for denouncing Herod Antipas's unlawful marriage to Herodias (14:3-4). Imprisonment lasted months before execution. Jewish messianic expectations emphasized judgment, liberation, and kingdom establishment. John proclaimed Jesus as judge with winnowing fork (3:12), expecting swift judgment. Instead, Jesus exercised mercy, delayed judgment, and extended grace. This tension—between expected immediate judgment and actual patient mercy—confused many, including John. Early Christians wrestled similarly with delayed second coming.
Questions for Reflection
How should we respond when God's actions don't match our expectations?
What does John's doubt despite previous certainty teach about faith amid suffering?
How can we maintain faith when prayers seem unanswered and circumstances deteriorate?
Related Resources
Explore related topics, people, and study resources to deepen your understanding of this passage.
Analysis & Commentary
John the Baptist, imprisoned by Herod, sends disciples to Jesus: 'Art thou he that should come, or do we look for another?' (συ ει ο ερχομενος η ετερον προσδοκωμεν). John's question reveals human doubt amid suffering. The one who proclaimed Jesus as Lamb of God (John 1:29) now questions. 'He that should come' (ο ερχομενος) refers to Messiah. John expected messianic judgment and kingdom establishment; instead he languishes in prison while Jesus teaches and heals. Suffering tests faith. John's honest question isn't unbelief but wrestling with unfulfilled expectations. Jesus welcomes honest questions and provides evidence rather than rebuke.