The burden of Dumah. He calleth to me out of Seir, Woe, watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?' Dumah refers to Edom (Seir is Edom's mountainous region). The oracle is brief and enigmatic. Someone from Edom calls to the watchman asking about the night—when will it end? What is its status? The doubled question emphasizes urgency and anxiety. 'Night' symbolizes judgment, darkness, suffering. Edom asks Israel's prophet for insight about how long their dark time will last. This demonstrates that even pagan nations recognized Israel's prophets had genuine revelation. The question models appropriate human response to divine judgment: seeking information from those with revealed knowledge rather than speculation. Yet the answer (verse 12) proves ambiguous, suggesting some questions lack clear answers—divine mysteries remain even for inquirers.
Historical Context
Edom, descended from Esau, maintained complex relationship with Israel—sometimes ally, often enemy. By Isaiah's time, Edom faced threats from growing empires. The name Dumah means 'silence,' possibly wordplay on Edom's fate—silence of death/judgment. Historically, Edom was eventually destroyed (Obadiah), though timing relative to this oracle is unclear. The brief oracle's enigmatic nature suggests prophetic reserve—not all inquiries receive clear answers. God reveals what He purposes to reveal; some questions remain mysterious. Church history shows similar patterns: believers experiencing suffering ask 'how long?' (Revelation 6:10), yet specific answers aren't always given. Faith must trust God's wisdom and timing even when detailed explanations are withheld. The oracle models this: seeking divine insight is right; demanding complete clarity isn't always granted.
Questions for Reflection
What does Edom seeking Israel's prophet teach about pagan recognition of genuine revelation?
How does the 'night' metaphor capture the experience of divine judgment?
Why does God sometimes withhold clear answers even to legitimate questions about suffering's duration?
Related Resources
Explore related topics, people, and study resources to deepen your understanding of this passage.
Analysis & Commentary
The burden of Dumah. He calleth to me out of Seir, Woe, watchman, what of the night? Watchman, what of the night?' Dumah refers to Edom (Seir is Edom's mountainous region). The oracle is brief and enigmatic. Someone from Edom calls to the watchman asking about the night—when will it end? What is its status? The doubled question emphasizes urgency and anxiety. 'Night' symbolizes judgment, darkness, suffering. Edom asks Israel's prophet for insight about how long their dark time will last. This demonstrates that even pagan nations recognized Israel's prophets had genuine revelation. The question models appropriate human response to divine judgment: seeking information from those with revealed knowledge rather than speculation. Yet the answer (verse 12) proves ambiguous, suggesting some questions lack clear answers—divine mysteries remain even for inquirers.