Ecclesiastes 3:7
A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
Original Language Analysis
Cross References
Historical Context
Garment-tearing was a powerful cultural symbol throughout Israelite history. Jacob rent his clothes when believing Joseph dead (Genesis 37:34); Job did so in grief (Job 1:20); Mordecai tore his garments at Haman's plot (Esther 4:1); the high priest rent his garments at Jesus's 'blasphemy' (Matthew 26:65). Sewing the torn garment symbolized recovery from crisis. Ancient Near Eastern culture valued both eloquent speech (especially in royal courts) and disciplined silence. The prophets had to discern when to speak uncomfortable truth versus when to remain silent before hardened hearts (Amos 5:13). Jesus modeled this wisdom: speaking boldly to religious leaders yet remaining silent before Herod (Luke 23:9). James later counseled believers to be 'swift to hear, slow to speak' (James 1:19), reflecting Ecclesiastes' wisdom about measured words.
Questions for Reflection
- What situations in your current season call for silence rather than hasty speech, and which require you to speak up despite fear or discomfort?
- How does this verse inform when to express grief openly (rending) versus when to move toward healing (sewing)?
Analysis & Commentary
This verse presents two sets of opposites related to communication and response. 'A time to rend, and a time to sew' refers to the ancient practice of tearing garments in grief, anguish, or repentance (Genesis 37:34; Joel 2:13), followed by later mending. The Hebrew 'qara' (קָרַע, rend/tear) signified deep emotional/spiritual crisis, while 'taphar' (תָּפַר, sew) indicated restoration and healing. The second pair—'a time to keep silence, and a time to speak'—addresses verbal wisdom. The Hebrew 'chasah' (חָשָׁה, keep silence) means purposeful, disciplined quiet, while 'dabar' (דָבַר, speak) indicates articulated expression. Proverbs extensively praises guarded speech (10:19, 17:28), yet Scripture also condemns cowardly silence when truth requires voice (Esther 4:14). The verse teaches that wisdom requires discernment about both emotional expression and verbal communication—knowing when symbolic actions or words serve God's purposes and when restraint does.