Numbers 11:20

Analysis & Commentary

The climax: 'But even a whole month' far exceeds the escalating progression of verse 19, shocking the hearers with the extent of God's provision-turned-judgment. The imagery 'until it come out at your nostrils' (Hebrew ad asher yetse' me'appekem, עַד אֲשֶׁר־יֵצֵא מֵאַפְּכֶם) vividly describes revulsion—meat would become so excessive that it would induce nausea and disgust. What they craved would become loathsome. This demonstrates the principle that sinful desires, when granted without restraint, produce disgust rather than delight.

The phrase 'it be loathsome unto you' (Hebrew vehaya lakem lezara, וְהָיָה לָכֶם לְזָרָא) indicates the meat would become repulsive, an object of horror rather than desire. The transformation from craving to disgust illustrates how sin promises satisfaction but delivers emptiness. What appeared desirable becomes detestable when consumed in rebellion rather than received in faith. This pattern appears in the prodigal son's experience (Luke 15:16) and characterizes all idolatrous pursuits—the desired object, once attained, reveals its inability to satisfy.

The explanation 'because that ye have despised the LORD which is among you' exposes the root sin: not merely wanting meat, but rejecting God's presence and provision. The Hebrew ma'astem (מְאַסְתֶּם) translated 'despised' means to reject, spurn, refuse—strong language indicating deliberate repudiation. Their complaint wasn't about food but about God Himself. The phrase 'which is among you' emphasizes God's immanent presence—Yahweh dwelt in the tabernacle among them, visible in cloud and fire, yet they despised Him. The final question 'Why came we forth out of Egypt?' summarizes their rebellion: questioning redemption itself, preferring bondage to freedom under God's leadership.

Historical Context

The month-long meat provision would be fulfilled through quail (verse 31-32), supernatural provision that became plague (verse 33). The historical account shows that many who ate died while the meat was still in their mouths (verse 33), demonstrating the severity of receiving sinful desires. The place was named Kibroth-hattaavah ('graves of craving,' verse 34), a permanent memorial to the danger of lusting after what God has not granted. This event became a warning throughout Israel's history (Psalm 78:26-31; 106:14-15) about the peril of demanding rather than trusting.

Questions for Reflection

• How does the progression from craving to revulsion illustrate the inevitable disappointment that follows when we pursue desires in rebellion against God?
• What does the accusation 'ye have despised the LORD which is among you' teach about how complaining against God's provision is actually rejecting God Himself?